You’ll find collectors enthusiastically pursuing several rare unicorn Beanie Babies in 2025, including the Aurora Bundle’s durable twin unicorns, Ty Lillibelle’s sparkly pink design, and the sought-after Beanie Baby Pegasus. Premium options like Gumball and Jellyroll feature glittering accents and ultra-soft materials, while discontinued models like Ramsey command higher prices. When selecting your next collectible, consider factors like material quality, size, and authenticity markers to make an informed investment. Let’s explore the specific details that make each unicorn Beanie Baby a valuable addition to your collection.
Key Takeaways
- The Beanie Baby Pegasus White Horse Unicorn remains highly sought-after for its environmentally friendly materials and sturdy construction for long-term collecting.
- Ty Lillibelle Pink Kitten with glitter eyes and weighted base commands premium prices due to its official Ty authentication and limited availability.
- Aurora Jellyroll Unicorn’s vibrant multicolored design and ultra-soft materials make it a rising star in unicorn Beanie Baby collections.
- Skylar Beanie Baby’s 2021 release date, official TY tag, and unique poem make it particularly valuable for serious collectors.
- Discontinued models like Ramsey, which combines lion and unicorn elements, are especially valuable due to their rarity and unique design features.
Aurora Bundle of 2 Stuffed Beanbag Unicorns
- Aqua colored Blueberry ripple the unicorn & cotton candy pink jellyroll the unicorn
- Bundle of 2 Mythical unicorn stuffed beanbag animals
- Each measures 7" Long x 5" Tall - perfect for little hands!
Parents seeking a safe and engaging first plush toy will find the Aurora Bundle of 2 Stuffed Beanbag Unicorns perfectly suited for children ages 12 months to 8 years. You’ll receive two adorable unicorns – the blue Blueberry Ripple and pink Jelly Roll – each measuring 7 inches long by 5 inches tall.
Each unicorn features randomly splotched fur in yellow, pink, and blue, complemented by sparkly silver horns and super-soft manes. The 100% polyester construction makes them durable and hand-washable, while their lightweight design (5.6 ounces) guarantees easy transport. With an impressive 4.8-star rating from 2,884 reviews, these plush companions have proven their worth through months of active play and cuddles.
Best For: Parents seeking soft, durable, and travel-friendly stuffed animals for toddlers and young children aged 12 months to 8 years who love colorful, imaginative play.
Pros:
- High-quality, washable polyester material that maintains softness and color over time
- Perfect size for small hands and travel, with lightweight design at 5.6 ounces
- Outstanding customer satisfaction with 4.8/5 stars from nearly 3,000 reviews
Cons:
- Limited to hand washing only, which may be inconvenient for some parents
- Indoor use only recommended, which may restrict play options
- Higher price point for size compared to similar plush toys in the market
Ty Beanie Bellies Lillibelle Pink Kitten Plush
- TY Beanie Bellies are the super soft and cuddly soft toys, with a soft tummy to caress;A cat made with great attention to detail Super soft with big sparkling eyes: the...
- Beanie Bellies is the line of soft plush toys with big colourful and glittery eyes inspired by the world of animals, nature or fantasy, all to embrace and collect
- Name: Lillibelle;Birthday: September 28th;Featuring the authentic Ty heart shaped plaque with the name and date of birth
Animal lovers seeking a high-quality plush companion will find the Ty Beanie Bellies Lillibelle Pink Kitten Plush particularly appealing, as it combines exceptional softness with thoughtful design features. Standing at 20 cm tall, this pink and white kitten boasts striking blue glitter eyes and a weighted base that keeps it sitting upright.
You’ll appreciate the attention to detail, from the authentic heart-shaped Ty plaque displaying Lillibelle’s September 28th birthday to the high-quality stitching that withstands washing. With a 4.8-star rating from over 600 customers, this collectible plush proves its worth through durability and charm, making it an excellent choice for both dedicated collectors and young enthusiasts alike.
Best For: Collectors of plush toys, children aged 3 and up, and anyone seeking a soft, high-quality stuffed animal that combines decorative appeal with durability.
Pros:
- Exceptional quality with durable stitching that maintains shape after washing
- Distinctive features including glittery blue eyes and weighted base for upright display
- High customer satisfaction rating (4.8/5) from over 600 reviews
Cons:
- Premium pricing compared to standard plush toys
- Limited functionality beyond display and basic play
- Size may be smaller than expected for some buyers at 20 cm (8 inches)
Beanie Baby Pegasus White Horse Unicorn Plush Toy 6inch
- Ty Stuffed Animals Plush Doll
This charming 6-inch Pegasus plush toy offers an ideal introduction to the world of collectible Beanie Babies, especially for young enthusiasts aged 3 and up who love mythical creatures. You’ll find its shimmering eyes and pristine white design particularly appealing, while the environmental protection plush material guarantees durability for years of enjoyment.
At just 1.76 ounces, this lightweight unicorn-horse hybrid from manufacturer yuanpulalala stands approximately 6 x 3 x 6 inches, making it perfectly sized for small hands and display shelves. Though it’s currently ranked #338,407 in Toys & Games, you’ll appreciate its quality construction and attention to detail that creates lasting childhood memories while maintaining collectible appeal.
Best For: Children aged 3 and up who love mythical creatures, unicorn collectors, and anyone seeking a durable, adorable plush toy for display or play.
Pros:
- High-quality environmental protection plush material ensures longevity
- Perfect 6-inch size for small hands and display purposes
- Attractive design with shimmering eyes appeals to both children and collectors
Cons:
- Relatively low sales ranking might indicate limited availability
- Higher price point compared to non-collectible plush toys
- Limited color options (only available in white)
ty – Beanie Boos Unicorn Gumball – 15 CM
- Gumball is a sweet unicorn with a pink fur with blue spots
- Gumball's birthday is August 13th
- Beanie Boo's are nice animals that you can play and cuddle with
Measuring 15 centimeters tall, the TY Beanie Boos Unicorn Gumball stands out as an ideal collectible for young enthusiasts and first-time Beanie Baby owners, thanks to its manageable size and enchanting design features.
You’ll find Gumball’s pink fur adorned with blue spots, while its glittering blue eyes, paws, and horn create an irresistible appeal. Born on August 13th, this candy-colored unicorn has earned a strong 4.7-star rating from 836 collectors. Despite its compact dimensions of 1.55 x 1.4 x 2.33 inches, you’re getting a well-crafted plush that’s perfect for both display and gentle play. It’s an excellent entry point for children aged 3 and up who are just beginning their collecting journey.
Best For: Young collectors aged 3 and up who are starting their Beanie Boo collection or looking for a small, portable unicorn plush toy with enchanting features.
Pros:
- High-quality construction with soft pink fur and attractive blue accents
- Perfect portable size at 15cm for easy carrying and display
- Strong customer satisfaction with 4.7/5 stars from 836 reviews
Cons:
- Relatively small dimensions may disappoint those expecting a larger plush
- Price point might be high relative to its compact size
- Limited play functionality compared to larger interactive toys
Aurora Vibrant Bright Fancies Jellyroll Unicorn Plush (7 Inches)
- This plush is approx. 10" x 8" x 5" in size
- Made from deluxe materials for a cloud-like softness!
- A vibrant design to make this plush unique!
Designed with delightful multi-colored patterns and ultra-soft materials, the Aurora Vibrant Bright Fancies Jellyroll Unicorn Plush offers young collectors and fantasy enthusiasts a charming addition to their plush menagerie.
You’ll find this 10 x 8 x 5-inch unicorn features cloud-like softness that’s perfect for cuddling, while its bean pellet filling provides just the right amount of stability. As part of Aurora’s fantasy creature collection, this plush stands out with its vibrant design that’ll spark your imagination. When you’re building your collection, you’ll appreciate how this unicorn’s deluxe materials guarantee long-lasting durability, making it a reliable addition to your growing assortment of plush companions.
Best For: Young children and fantasy plush collectors who appreciate vibrant, colorful designs and soft, cuddly stuffed animals.
Pros:
- Exceptionally soft and cloud-like material perfect for cuddling
- Bean pellet filling provides good stability and weight distribution
- Part of a larger fantasy collection with unique, eye-catching designs
Cons:
- Size discrepancy between title (7 inches) and product description (10 x 8 x 5 inches)
- May be too small for older children or those seeking larger plush toys
- Premium materials may require special care for cleaning and maintenance
TY Toys Beanie Babies Unicorn Skylar – 15 CM, Pink,2009125
- Beanie Baby Skylar is a 6 inch tall unicorn
- Beanie Babies are cute TY stuffed animals in the shape of your favorite animals
- Skylar has a soft pink with orange fur and a golden horn
Parents and collectors seeking a perfect blend of collectibility and child-friendly charm will find their match in TY’s Skylar unicorn Beanie Baby. At 15 centimeters tall, this pink, orange, and white plush companion features a golden horn and signature glittery blue eyes that’ll capture your heart.
You’ll appreciate Skylar’s thoughtful design elements, including her super-soft fur texture and compact size that’s perfect for small hands. Her official TY heart tag, complete with a birthday (May 22) and poem, adds genuine collectible value. Released in 2021, this 4.7-star-rated plush has already proven itself as a beloved addition to both playrooms and collections, combining durability with the dreamy aesthetic that makes unicorn Beanie Babies particularly sought-after.
Best For: Young children, collectors of TY Beanie Babies, and unicorn enthusiasts seeking a soft, durable, and collectible plush toy that combines play value with sentimental appeal.
Pros:
- High-quality soft materials and detailed design features including glittery eyes and golden horn
- Compact 15cm size perfect for small hands and easy portability
- Includes collectible value with official TY heart tag, birthday, and poem
Cons:
- Small size may disappoint those expecting a larger plush toy
- Premium pricing compared to non-collectible plush toys
- Limited availability as a collectible item may make it difficult to find
TY 1607-36252 36252 Beanie Boos Ramsey Lion, Multicolored, 15 cm
- Unicorn Plush Lion 15cm
- Irresistible With its soft fur and its extremely large shiny eyes.
- From Other Animals to Numerous Collect In the Beanie Boo range, in sizes 15 cm, 23 cm and 41 cm, and key ring.
Looking for a magical hybrid plush that combines the majesty of a lion with the enchantment of a unicorn? You’ll find exactly that in Ramsey, TY’s beloved 15cm Beanie Boo that’s charming collectors worldwide. This unique plush features a brown lion’s body with a full mane, adorned with a distinctive unicorn horn and signature sparkly eyes.
With an impressive 4.8-star rating from over 6,700 reviews, Ramsey’s soft, cuddly design makes it a standout addition to any collection. Released in 2018, this discontinued piece has become increasingly sought-after. You’ll appreciate its compact size, quality construction, and whimsical backstory – born a lion who magically grew a horn, making it an enchanting blend of two magical creatures.
Best For: Children aged 3+ and collectors who love unique, magical plush toys combining different animal characteristics and appreciate the quality of TY Beanie Boos.
Pros:
- High-quality soft plush material with excellent durability, backed by overwhelmingly positive customer reviews
- Unique design combining lion and unicorn features, making it a distinctive collector’s item
- Compact 15cm size makes it perfect for carrying around and displaying
Cons:
- Discontinued by manufacturer, making it potentially harder to find and more expensive
- Requires a 9V battery (purpose not specified in product details)
- Some units reported to have minor manufacturing imperfections like bent ears
Beanie Baby Enchanted Unicorn owl Stuffed Animal Plush Doll (6inch)
- Ty Enchanted Stuffed Animals Plush Doll
The Beanie Baby Enchanted Unicorn owl offers young collectors a perfect entry point into the world of plush collectibles, while its 6-inch size makes it ideal for small hands and easy transport. You’ll appreciate its environmentally friendly plush material and high safety standards, making it suitable for children ages 3 and up.
At just 3.31 ounces and featuring large, shiny eyes alongside its distinctive unicorn horn, this multicolored plush has earned a perfect 5-star rating from collectors. You’ll find it’s well-crafted for durability, and its compact 3 x 2 x 4-inch dimensions make it an excellent display piece. While ranked #169,654 in Toys & Games, don’t let that number fool you – this yuanpulalala-manufactured piece is rapidly gaining popularity among serious collectors.
Best For: Young children aged 3+ who love collecting plush toys or are drawn to magical creatures like unicorns and owls, particularly those who appreciate soft, portable stuffed animals.
Pros:
- High-quality, environmentally friendly plush material ensures safety and durability
- Perfect 5-star rating indicates consistent customer satisfaction
- Compact 6-inch size makes it ideal for small hands and easy to carry around
Cons:
- Relatively low ranking in Toys & Games category (#169,654) suggests limited popularity
- Limited review base of only 5 customers may not provide comprehensive feedback
- Manufactured in China, which may raise quality consistency concerns for some buyers
Ty Beanie Boos PIXY – White Unicorn reg
- Meet pixy! A White, one-of-a-kind unicorn accessorized in accents of textured rainbow glitter The magical Queen of unicorns, is made of soft Ty silk fabric.
- Pixy has super soft fabric perfect for snuggling
- Pixy is a magical Unicorn that will keep you company all day long
Soft, sparkly, and adorable, Ty Beanie Boos PIXY represents a significant upgrade for unicorn enthusiasts who’ve grown up with traditional Beanie Babies. You’ll notice the high-quality fabrics and attention to detail, from the shimmering sequins to the perfectly crafted features that make this plush truly special.
Whether you’re buying for a young collector or seeking a decorative piece, PIXY’s larger size and durability make it an excellent choice. You’ll find it’s equally suited for cuddling, display, or gentle play. While you might notice slightly compressed ears upon unboxing, they’ll quickly fluff up to match PIXY’s overall charm that’s made it a standout favorite among Beanie Boo collectors.
Best For: Young collectors, unicorn enthusiasts, and anyone seeking a high-quality plush toy that combines visual appeal with durability for both play and display purposes.
Pros:
- Premium quality materials and construction with soft, high-grade fabrics
- Eye-catching design featuring sparkly sequins and glitter accents
- Versatile size making it perfect for both cuddling and decorative display
Cons:
- Ears may arrive compressed from packaging and require time to regain shape
- Higher price point compared to standard plush toys
- Actual appearance might slightly differ from online product images
Ty Beanie Boos Fantasia – Multicolor Unicorn reg
- Meet Fantasia! A candy-colored, one-of-a-kind unicorn accessorized in accents of textured gold glitter The magical Queen of unicorns, is made of soft Ty silk fabric.
- Fantasia has super soft fabric perfect for snuggling
- Fantasia is a magical Unicorn that will keep you company all day long
Parents and collectors seeking a high-quality unicorn plush will find Ty Beanie Boos Fantasia an exceptional choice, particularly since its vibrant multicolor design appeals to children aged 3-8 years old. You’ll appreciate the soft Ty silk fabric construction, featuring pink, purple, and blue hues accented with gold glitter details on the horn.
At 3 x 2 x 6 inches and just over 3 ounces, this well-constructed plush maintains its quality even after washing, though you’ll want to note that some glitter shedding may occur. With its large sparkling eyes and durable stitching, Fantasia ranks impressively with a 4.7-star rating from over 3,500 reviews, making it a smart investment for both play and collecting.
Best For: Children ages 3-8, unicorn enthusiasts, and Beanie Boo collectors seeking a high-quality, visually appealing plush toy that’s both durable and cuddly.
Pros:
- Premium soft Ty silk fabric with vibrant multicolor design and glitter accents
- Excellent durability with strong stitching and washable construction
- High customer satisfaction with 4.7/5 stars from over 3,500 reviews
Cons:
- Glitter may shed onto furniture or clothing
- Size may be smaller than expected at 3 x 2 x 6 inches
- Price point may be higher compared to non-collectible plush toys
Factors to Consider When Choosing a Unicorn Beanie Baby
When you’re looking to choose the perfect unicorn Beanie Baby, you’ll want to carefully evaluate key factors like size compatibility for the intended age group, material quality, and overall durability. The design elements, including color schemes, horn details, and facial expressions, should captivate your child while meeting essential safety standards through secure stitching and child-safe components. Your budget should align with the quality you’re seeking, as higher-end unicorn Beanie Babies often feature premium materials and construction that can withstand years of playtime.
Size and Age Range
Selecting the right size of unicorn Beanie Baby plays a crucial role in your child’s enjoyment and safety. You’ll want to look for plush toys that measure between 6 inches and 20 centimeters for younger children, ensuring they can easily grasp and handle their new companion.
When shopping for your little one, always check the age recommendation label, which typically suggests ages 3 and up. If you’re buying for an older child, you might consider larger sizes that offer more cuddling potential, while toddlers do better with smaller, lightweight options they can carry around. Remember that portability matters, especially if you’re planning to use the Beanie Baby as a travel buddy. Most importantly, verify that the size doesn’t present any safety concerns, particularly regarding small parts that could pose choking hazards.
Material and Durability
The durability of your unicorn Beanie Baby’s materials directly impacts its longevity and your child’s enjoyment. When selecting your plush companion, look for high-quality polyester fabric that’s both soft and sturdy, guaranteeing countless cuddles without compromising quality.
You’ll want to examine the seams carefully, as they’re vital stress points that need reinforced stitching to withstand active play. Pay special attention to areas around the horn, legs, and neck where children tend to grip and tug. The best unicorn Beanie Babies feature stain-resistant surfaces that you can easily wipe clean, maintaining their pristine appearance through everyday adventures.
Check that the filling, whether it’s premium fiberfill or traditional bean pellets, is evenly distributed throughout the plush toy. This ensures your unicorn maintains its shape and provides consistent comfort during playtime.
Design and Color Appeal
Since visual appeal plays a crucial role in your unicorn Beanie Baby’s charm, you’ll want to contemplate several key design elements before making your selection. Look for vibrant colors and eye-catching patterns that’ll make your piece stand out in any collection.
When evaluating design appeal, consider these essential features:
- Sparkle elements like glitter or sequins that create magical accents
- Large, expressive eyes that bring personality to the unicorn’s face
- Complementary color schemes, especially pastels or rainbow combinations
- Multi-colored fur textures that add dimension and interest
- Balanced proportions between cute and fantastical elements
You’ll find the most sought-after pieces combine these features thoughtfully, creating an irresistible blend of whimsy and collectibility that appeals to both young enthusiasts and serious collectors alike.
Safety and Construction
When choosing a unicorn Beanie Baby, safety and construction quality should be your top priorities, especially if you’re purchasing for young collectors. You’ll want to verify the plush is made from non-toxic materials, specifically looking for BPA-free polyester or eco-friendly plush fabrics that meet safety standards.
Check the following essential elements before making your selection:
- Examine all seams for tight, secure stitching without loose threads
- Look for safety certifications like ASTM F963 or EN71
- Verify that decorative elements, such as sparkly manes or horns, are firmly attached
- Test the overall construction by gently tugging at different points
Price Vs Quality Value
Making smart purchasing decisions for unicorn Beanie Babies requires carefully weighing price against quality value, especially as costs can vary substantially between different models and brands.
When you’re evaluating your options, look for plush toys with durable stitching and vibrant colors, as these features often indicate better craftsmanship. While you’ll find budget-friendly unicorns around $10-15, premium versions with enhanced detailing and superior materials typically range from $25-40. You’ll want to contemplate how long you expect the Beanie Baby to last, particularly if it’s for a child’s regular play versus collecting.
Before investing in pricier limited editions, check customer reviews to verify that you’re getting genuine quality improvements rather than just paying for rarity. Sometimes, mid-range options offer the best balance of durability and affordability.
Frequently Asked Questions
How Do I Authenticate a Rare Unicorn Beanie Baby?
To authenticate your rare unicorn Beanie Baby, you’ll need to examine several key features. Check the tush tag for the generation marker, production location, and PE pellet information. Verify that the hang tag matches the correct production year and shows no signs of tampering. Inspect the fabric quality, stitching pattern, and horn details against official Ty references. You can also consult professional authentication services or experienced collectors for verification.
What Cleaning Methods Are Safe for Vintage Unicorn Beanie Babies?
To safely clean your vintage unicorn Beanie Baby, you’ll want to start with a gentle spot-cleaning approach. Use a soft, slightly damp cloth with mild soap and water, carefully dabbing (never rubbing) any soiled areas. Avoid harsh chemicals, bleach, or machine washing, as these can damage the fabric and pellets. For dusty unicorns, try using a soft-bristled brush or compressed air. Always air dry completely, and never use heat or direct sunlight.
Where Can I Find Original Purchase Receipts for Collectible Unicorns?
Like searching for a needle in a haystack, finding original receipts for vintage Beanie Babies requires exploring multiple channels. You’ll have the best luck checking eBay listings where sellers sometimes include original documentation, connecting with specialized Beanie Baby collector groups on Facebook, or reaching out to former retailers who might have archived records. If you can’t locate receipts, you can verify authenticity through TY’s official product codes and hang tags instead.
Do Manufacturing Defects Increase a Unicorn Beanie Baby’s Value?
Manufacturing defects can substantially increase your Beanie Baby’s value, but it’s essential to verify they’re authentic factory errors rather than damage. You’ll find that misprinted tags, wrong-colored materials, or misaligned stitching are among the most valuable defects. For example, a unicorn with reversed ear placement or missing horn embroidery could fetch 2-3 times the standard price. However, you’ll need documentation or expert authentication to prove the defect’s legitimacy.
Which Unicorn Beanie Babies Were Exclusively Released in Other Countries?
You’ll find several exclusive international unicorn Beanie Babies, including Mystic the Unicorn (UK version) with a Union Jack symbol, and Sparkles the Unicorn (Japan exclusive) featuring sakura flower designs. The Canadian market received Crystal the Unicorn with a maple leaf emblem, while Australia got Rainbow the Unicorn sporting distinctive outback-themed tags. These regional variants are particularly sought-after by collectors, as they weren’t widely distributed in other markets.
